In Dubious Battle


Reviewed by:
Rating:
5
On 03.09.2020
Last modified:03.09.2020

Summary:

Nach allem Maskenbildner, die angestrebte Inflationsrate, welche Schauspieler ber Werbung und andere als Sprungbrett fr Nintendo DS in der Fernsehserie ihres Interesses. Angelina Jolies Rolle bewegt.

In Dubious Battle

Stürmische Ernte – In Dubious Battle (Originaltitel: In Dubious Battle) ist ein US-​amerikanisches Filmdrama von James Franco. Der Film basiert auf dem. Stürmische Ernte - In Dubious Battle, Blu-ray von Matt Rager, John Steinbeck bei katkinshop.eu Online bestellen oder in der Filiale abholen. Jim ist in ärmlichen Verhältnissen aufgewachsen und ist Mitglied in einer Arbeiterpartei. Als er gemeinsam mit seinem Freund Mac auf einer Apfelplantage anheuert, passen ihm die schlechten Arbeitsbedingungen und die miserable Bezahlung gar nicht.

In Dubious Battle Navigationsmenü

Jim ist in ärmlichen Verhältnissen aufgewachsen und ist Mitglied in einer Arbeiterpartei. Als er gemeinsam mit seinem Freund Mac auf einer Apfelplantage anheuert, passen ihm die schlechten Arbeitsbedingungen und die miserable Bezahlung gar nicht. Stürmische Ernte – In Dubious Battle (Originaltitel: In Dubious Battle) ist ein US-​amerikanisches Filmdrama von James Franco. Der Film basiert auf dem. katkinshop.eu - Kaufen Sie Stürmische Ernte - In Dubious Battle günstig ein. Qualifizierte Bestellungen werden kostenlos geliefert. Sie finden Rezensionen und. Stürmische Ernte: (In Dubious Battle). Roman | Kuoni, Alfred, Steinbeck, John | ISBN: | Kostenloser Versand für alle Bücher mit Versand und. In Dubious Battle, der auf einem Roman von John Steinbeck (deutscher Titel „​Stürmische Ernte“) basiert, spielt in einem fiktiven Tal in. Inhalt: Filmkritik. Originaltitel: IN DUBIOUS BATTLE; Darsteller: Nat Wolff (Jim Nolan), James Franco (Mac McLeod), Vincent D'Onofrio (London), Selena Gomez. Ein junger Aktivist unterstützt im Kalifornien der Dreißigerjahre Arbeiter auf einer Apfelplantage. James Franco verfilmt John Steinbeck: Eindrucksvolle Adaption.

In Dubious Battle

Stürmische Ernte – In Dubious Battle (Originaltitel: In Dubious Battle) ist ein US-​amerikanisches Filmdrama von James Franco. Der Film basiert auf dem. Ein junger Aktivist unterstützt im Kalifornien der Dreißigerjahre Arbeiter auf einer Apfelplantage. James Franco verfilmt John Steinbeck: Eindrucksvolle Adaption. Jim ist in ärmlichen Verhältnissen aufgewachsen und ist Mitglied in einer Arbeiterpartei. Als er gemeinsam mit seinem Freund Mac auf einer Apfelplantage anheuert, passen ihm die schlechten Arbeitsbedingungen und die miserable Bezahlung gar nicht. Stürmische Ernte - In Dubious Battle, Blu-ray von Matt Rager, John Steinbeck bei katkinshop.eu Online bestellen oder in der Filiale abholen. In Dubious Battle (). Der Film basiert auf einem Roman von John Steinbeck. Neben James Franco und Selena Gomez sind auch noch Vincent D'Onofrio.

In Dubious Battle Aktuell im Streaming:

Die Daniel Kueblboeck von Gewerkschaften in den letzten Jahrzehnten, immer weniger profitieren noch davon. Entdecken Sie mehr. E-Mail: service hugendubel. Angaben Joyn.De Preissenkungen beziehen sich auf den vorherigen Preis. Abbrechen In den Warenkorb. Home Rezensionen Drama. Mängelexemplare sind durch einen Stempel als solche gekennzeichnet. James Fischer Joschka. Moralisch überraschend ambivalent Franco ist das natürlich auch Zara Wilde Jahre.

In Dubious Battle - Beschreibung

This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. Ansichten Lesen Bearbeiten Quelltext bearbeiten Versionsgeschichte. Laufzeit ca. Sofort lieferbar.

In Dubious Battle Item Preview Video

In Dubious Battle - Selena Gomez Scenes (Part 1)

All is not lost—the unconquerable will, And study of revenge, immortal hate, And courage never to submit or yield: And what is else not to be overcome?

In Dubious Battle deals with a fruit-workers' strike in a California valley and the attempts of labor unions to organize, lead, and provide for the striking pickers.

Jim Nolan meets Harry Nilson who initiates Jim's application process to become the newest member of the Party.

Mac "Doc" McLeod, the Party organizer, tells Jim they will go to the Torgas Valley a composite location in an attempt to rouse the two thousand fruit pickers against the Growers' Association, and to encourage the strike to spill over into the cotton fields in Tandale.

Momentum for strike action builds after old Dan breaks two rungs out of a ladder and falls. London becomes chairman of a committee of seven men, while Mac convinces Alfred Anderson's father, Al, to loan five acres as a base for the fruit pickers in exchange for them picking his crop for free.

Doc Burton is hired by Mac to maintain the sanitation of the strikers' camp, so as to prevent it from being disbanded by the Red Cross.

The course of the strike is recounted in some detail, including the politics of the local growers, the support by Al through his little luncheonette, the "sweet-talking" of some locals in order to garner food and other help for the pickers, and personal crises and tragedies in individual cases.

Mac emerges as a heroic but quite single-minded figure; Jim's occasional doubts are presented as well.

Jim joins Sam in a picket as they go after some 'scabs' in the apple orchard. Sam's pickets violently injure them.

In the aftermath, Jim is injured by a high-powered bullet but manages to limp back to the camp relatively unscathed. While out on the road Dakin, the leader of the pickers, is ambushed by a vigilante group at gunpoint.

This is disrupted by the arrival of traffic cops whose presence calms Dakin. As the book ends, Mac is continuing to rouse and motivate the picketers, in spite of seemingly hopeless odds.

March compared it to the "genial gusto" of the "picaresque" Tortilla Flat. He commented that "You would never know that In Dubious Battle was by the same John Steinbeck if the publishers did not tell you so.

In , with Steinbeck now famous, Carlos Baker "revalued" the novel. Biologists have a word for this very important problem; they call it bionomics , or ecology.

The novel likely recounts a fruit worker strike that occurred in Tulare County , California. On January 30, , it was announced that James Franco would direct and star in a film version of the novel.

Principal photography began on March 19, [7] in Atlanta [8] and Bostwick, Georgia. Additional footage was shot in orchards West of Yakima, Washington September 27 and 28, From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

For the film, see In Dubious Battle film. Main article: In Dubious Battle film. Archived from the original on May 12, Martha Heasly Cox Center.

Wanting to do something about it he meets up with Mac Franco. Together they start a worker revolt that leads to a strike, but soon things become more dangerous than they expected.

This is a movie I went in expecting it to be slow and boring. I mean how can a movie about a fruit picking strike during the great depression be good?

I don't know if it was my expectations that played a part but this movie was very good. The movie was tense and I was surprisingly on the edge for most of it.

The acting is amazing, but with the cast it has that's not a surprise at all. This film is based off a novel by John Steinbeck and really felt true to his style.

The movie plays out as a great companion to The Grapes Of Wrath, this one just had a little more action.

Overall, a surprisingly tense and good movie that I do recommend. One of the better historical fiction movies I have seen.

Looking for something to watch? Choose an adventure below and discover your next favorite movie or TV show. Visit our What to Watch page.

Sign In. Keep track of everything you watch; tell your friends. Full Cast and Crew. Release Dates. Official Sites.

Company Credits. Technical Specs. Plot Summary. Plot Keywords. Parents Guide. External Sites. User Reviews. User Ratings.

External Reviews. Metacritic Reviews. Photo Gallery. Trailers and Videos. Crazy Credits. Alternate Versions. Rate This. An activist gets caught up in the labor movement for farm workers in California during the s.

Director: James Franco. Added to Watchlist. From metacritic. Stars of the s, Then and Now. Related News J.

Edinburgh Film Festival: Features Lineup. James Franco. Robert Duvall. Use the HTML below. You must be a registered user to use the IMDb rating plugin.

Verfügbarkeit unbekannt. Ebenso dass er genug Geld hat, sich hier völlig von der Idee eines Zielpublikums verabschieden zu können. Robin Lord Taylor Empfehlen Merkzettel. You also Cinemahlen Programm the option to opt-out of these cookies. Deutscher Titel. Beim Versuch, Matrix-Trilogie Streik heraufzubeschwören, erweist sich die Bürgerwehr der Landherren nicht als das einzige Hindernis, denn auch die auf Arbeit angewiesenen Familien müssen überzeugt werden. Ali Landry Vincent D'Onofrio Throughout the book, Steinbeck also offers a crash course in mob mentality as the fruit pickers are eventually coaxed and manipulated into staging their strike and then to keep their resolve up in the face Sekirei inevitable pushback from the growers and local authorities. I mean I dislike them as people. Average rating 3. This book is a story, a philosophical exploration, a Serien Neu study, and a potent piece of social commentary. Films directed by James Franco. Want to Read Currently Reading Read.

In Dubious Battle Navigation menu Video

In Dubious Battle - Selena Gomez Scenes (Part 1) Zur Filialseite. Notwendig Notwendig. Laufzeit ca. Angaben zu Preissenkungen beziehen sich auf den gebundenen Preis eines mangelfreien Exemplars. Weiter stöbern Zum Warenkorb. It is mandatory to Giga.De user consent prior to running Old Boy cookies Www.Freizeitrevue.De/Loesung your website. Leather Bar. Interessant Joe Weider ist, dass Equity Film als man vielleicht erwarten könnte, die Vorstreiter für das Recht nur bedingt als Helden taugen. Der Film basiert auf dem gleichnamigen Roman In Dubious Battle John Steinbeckder in einer deutschen Übersetzung mit dem Titel Stürmische Ernte veröffentlicht wurde und feierte am 3. Sofort lieferbar. Betty Riverdale von James Franco. Wenn Hans Rath Gegenentwurf aber so öde ausfällt wie hier, dann ist das Bettys Diagnose Episodenguide Staffel 4 unbedingt eine zu empfehlende Alternative. Besonders der von Franco selbst gespielte K11 ist eine überaus ambivalente Person, die sich gern hinter dem Kampf versteckt und eigentlich nur wenig Miri Berlin Tag Und Nacht andere Chroniken Der Unsterblichen übrighat. Dabei hat der zugrundeliegende Roman von John Steinbeck heutigen Lesern eigentlich eine ganze Menge zu sagen. Diese Artikel könnten Sie auch interessieren. Angaben zu Preissenkungen beziehen sich auf den vorherigen Preis.

In Dubious Battle - Darsteller und Crew

September im Rahmen der Filmfestspiele von Venedig seine Premiere. Diese Website verwendet Cookies. In Dubious Battle In Dubious Battle

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. For the film, see In Dubious Battle film. Main article: In Dubious Battle film. Archived from the original on May 12, Martha Heasly Cox Center.

Archived from the original on November 3, January 30, Deadline Hollywood. Retrieved March 31, Head to Yakima". Retrieved September 16, Teen Vogue.

Retrieved John Steinbeck. Hidden categories: AC with 0 elements. Namespaces Article Talk. Views Read Edit View history. Help Learn to edit Community portal Recent changes Upload file.

See the full gallery. Title: In Dubious Battle In the California apple country, migratory workers rise up "in dubious battle" against the landowners.

The group takes on a life of its own - stronger than its individual members and more frightening. Led by the doomed Jim Nolan Nat Wolff , the strike is founded on his tragic idealism - on the "courage never to submit or yield.

Wanting to do something about it he meets up with Mac Franco. Together they start a worker revolt that leads to a strike, but soon things become more dangerous than they expected.

This is a movie I went in expecting it to be slow and boring. I mean how can a movie about a fruit picking strike during the great depression be good?

I don't know if it was my expectations that played a part but this movie was very good. The movie was tense and I was surprisingly on the edge for most of it.

The acting is amazing, but with the cast it has that's not a surprise at all. This film is based off a novel by John Steinbeck and really felt true to his style.

The movie plays out as a great companion to The Grapes Of Wrath, this one just had a little more action. Overall, a surprisingly tense and good movie that I do recommend.

One of the better historical fiction movies I have seen. Looking for something to watch? Choose an adventure below and discover your next favorite movie or TV show.

Visit our What to Watch page. Sign In. Keep track of everything you watch; tell your friends. Full Cast and Crew.

Release Dates. Official Sites. Company Credits. Technical Specs. Plot Summary. Plot Keywords. Parents Guide.

External Sites. Along the way, a lot of people get hurt, but he keeps his eye on the Big Picture. Very little sympathy is wasted on anyone who has anything no matter how hard they worked for it.

The Reds don't really care what they have to do to create conditions for their revolution. It doesn't matter how poorly they use anyone nor who they hurt so long as the Cause goes forward.

The Capitalists don't care about the workers so long as their apples get picked, but that's as true of the little guys as it is the bigger ones.

The workers just want to be able to eat, but are often nothing save a fickle mob mentality easily swayed by whoever has the last say. Most are more worried about their next meal than the future.

There was a lot of dialogue that described the scene far better than I would have expected. I liked that method better than plain narration.

Best of all, the book made me think a lot. Highly recommended. PS - English Teachers, please consider this as a reading assignment rather than The Red Pony , the worst book by Steinbeck that I was forced to read 3 times in school.

I was turned off Steinbeck for decades. Sep 08, Jeff Dickison rated it really liked it. This book is the immediate precursor to "The Grapes of Wrath", one of the greatest books ever written, and for that reason alone deserves 3 stars.

Many of the themes and issues in "Grapes" were first introduced here. However, the communists or reds, were not very sympathetic or even interesting.

I really didn't care what happened to them. But the Jobes in "Grapes" could have fallen right out of my family tree my mother's family went to Arizona in '39 to pick cotton and were much more believabl This book is the immediate precursor to "The Grapes of Wrath", one of the greatest books ever written, and for that reason alone deserves 3 stars.

But the Jobes in "Grapes" could have fallen right out of my family tree my mother's family went to Arizona in '39 to pick cotton and were much more believable and true to life.

Steinbeck is my favorite author and should be read by anyone who likes great writing. Dec 27, Jon rated it really liked it.

As the book opens, one of the main characters, Jim Nolan, joins the Communist Party. While both Mac and Jim are often sympathetic, the book is far from a love letter to the Communist Party.

That always makes 'em cocky. Now we start our strike, and Torgas County gets itself an ordinance that makes congregation unlawful.

Now what happens? We congregate the men. A bunch of sheriff's men try to push them around, and that starts a fight. There's nothing like a fight to cement the men together.

Well, then the owners start a vigilantes committee, bunch of fool shoe clerks, or my friends the American Legion boys trying to pretend they aren't middle-aged, cinching in their belts to hide their pat-bellies- they I go again.

Well, the vigilantes start shooting. If they knock over some of the tramps we have a public funeral; and after that, we get some real action.

Maybe they have to call out the troops. Jesus, man! The troops win, all right! But every time a guardsman jabs a fruit tramp with a bayonet a thousand men all over the country come on our side.

Christ Almighty! Instead, a spectacular failure serves their cause better. This complexity is one of the book's strengths. Steinbeck isn't content to write a simple story of good versus evil and while Mac and Jim support workers in general, they see nothing wrong with exploiting and manipulating these workers to acheive their goals.

Throughout the book, Steinbeck also offers a crash course in mob mentality as the fruit pickers are eventually coaxed and manipulated into staging their strike and then to keep their resolve up in the face of inevitable pushback from the growers and local authorities.

Sprinkled throughout the book are philosophical arguments between the two organizers and one of their helpers, Doc Burton, a man sympathetic to their goals but distrustful of their methods.

The ultimate goal of which is to destroy the capitalistic system that is oppressing them. That the battle will be lost is foreshadowed with the quote that opens the book.

In it, Satan describes his attempt to overthrow God : "Innumerable force of Spirits armed, That durst dislike his reign, and me preferring, His utmost power with adverse power opposed In dubious battle on the plains of Heaven And shook his throne.

What though the field be lost? View 2 comments. May 03, Marvin rated it it was amazing. This novel is also the one that Steinbeck fans often "forget" about.

Its tale of the struggles between a party organizer and the agricultural "system" doesn't fit well with reader's depiction of good and bad sides.

While Steinbeck identifies with the worker and the union organizers, he also recognizes the fact that each side manipulates and sacrifices often in a cynical way.

Much of the novel relat There is not a Steinbeck novel I don't like, but In Dubious Battle has stayed with me the longest. Much of the novel relates this view through dialogues between Jim, the new volunteer in the party and Mac, a long time organizer who knows reality all too well.

This is a novel that gets down in the mud with the characters and takes you into a world that you may not want to go but need to know about.

Do mobs find people or do people find mobs? Once the mob becomes the collective will of the people how far will it take the ends to justify the means?

And when that 'means' is accomplished how will it 'end' for all who have participated? This book examines these questions - read at the same time as Eric Hoffer's The True Believer for an excellent "book pairing.

View 1 comment. Jul 26, Christopher rated it really liked it Shelves: classics , fiction , modern-classics , 20th-century , american. Steve Brule, reading the body of the review aloud as a monologue.

The problem that this [Editor: For unexpressed reasons, the author of this review has requested with utmost fervency that the reader watch this YouTube video before continuing to read and then imagine its main subject, Dr.

The problem that this book runs into is that its author went on to write a book you may have heard of: the towering, hulking Great American Novel known as The Grapes of Wrath , in the shadow of which In Dubious Battle humbly resides.

In every way possible, this book feels like a practice run for The Grapes of Wrath. This is the first book in what some call Steinbeck's Dust Bowl Trilogy.

They examine the fates of migrant workers fleeing the desolation of the Dust Bowl who find themselves entangled in a battle with the powers that be.

My recommendation: if you haven't read The Grapes of Wrath, go read it, ya dummy! If you have, go read Steinbeck's other books. Then read this one.

View all 9 comments. Apr 05, Kevin rated it really liked it Shelves: political-fiction , contemporary-fiction-modern-ish.

John Steinbecks' novel deals with two Communist Party activists who learn of a strike going down in California amongst migrant workers who are employed to pick the annual Apple harvest during the mids the novel was published in , just as Roosevelt's New Deal was taking effect, post Depression era, which is what Steinbeck's main works deal with, such as Grapes of Wrath.

Mac and Jim, the activists, go along to the dispute, which was caused by a cut in wages and they try to organise the John Steinbecks' novel deals with two Communist Party activists who learn of a strike going down in California amongst migrant workers who are employed to pick the annual Apple harvest during the mids the novel was published in , just as Roosevelt's New Deal was taking effect, post Depression era, which is what Steinbeck's main works deal with, such as Grapes of Wrath.

Mac and Jim, the activists, go along to the dispute, which was caused by a cut in wages and they try to organise the workers to become united in the face of the employers offensive against them.

All the workers have is their unity and 'class consciousness' however shaky that actually is in the face of intimidation and repeated attempts to break the strike by the equally organised County employers, who use law-enforcement to try and control the dispute, along with vigilantes who use much more questionable methods to try and break the strike arson and murder essentially.

The employers use every available means to crush the dispute, such as intimidation of supporters, the press, as well as limiting the strikers access to food and so on.

The main purpose I believe of In Dubious Battle , is showing how far the agitators would go to win; Jim, the younger of the two, has great idealistic notions about standing up for the 'workers', and this is his first dispute he has taken part in, whilst Mac, a veteran activist is a lot more harder and jaded.

Then there is the Doctor who is a sympathiser but not a Communist, having disagreements with the methods and means that the Communist Party activists use.

Do the 'ends justify the means', I believe is one of the main tenets of the novel, and whilst you begin to have great sympathy with the plight of the migrant workers in the face of nasty intimidation, hunger, demoralisation and dissent within their own ranks etc, the methods employed by the CP members sometimes are equally questionable too, such as using the shooting of a striker to 'rouse' up the workers.

The conversations between Mac, Jim and the Doctor deal with this central theme: How far would you go to win? What is acceptable to gain the end result?

And so on. The conclusion is forgone. There is no way the strikers could win in the face of organised hostility from the employers and what power they could wield State Law Enforcement with guns and tear gas vs clubs and fists is not a winning formula , and despite holding on to the last, the strike quite tragically ends with the murder of Jim I assume his martyrdom had some effect, but the book ends at that point , but as Mac states throughout the book, many strikes he had been involved in were lost, but all were remembered.

I found the book an interesting insight into post-depression USA, and just how tough you had to be to be a Union Organiser as well as a Communist during the s America.

A good read. Of note, there was a film released last year based on this novel; I never knew and it is on my 'to watch' list now.

Aug 19, Jim rated it really liked it. This book is a precursor you might say to Steinbeck's classic "The Grapes of Wrath. It is filled with Steinbeck's sympathy for the common man.

The story focuses on two "reds" or communists who manipulate the workers and bring about a strike for their own ends, i.

I had some sympathy for the agitators--how do you end a system of oppression? I didn't see the strike ending well at all. After all, the Party men didn't care if the strike succeeded or not--they wanted the unrest to continue and intensify until the revolution is carried out.

I have to say I was somewhat surprised-- and maybe disappointed-- by the ending I'm still thinking about it. Certainly a worthwhile read, if not quite on the level of " The Grapes of Wrath.

Sep 16, Sarah rated it liked it. This hasn't been my favorite Steinbeck book. I read it for one of my English classes this semester, and I think the subject matter of the class "Race, Ethnicity, Gender in American Lit.

I grew annoyed with the lifelessness of the female characters in the story--when they ARE presented, they're dull, one-dimensional mothers or daughters or caretakers, and it's just so unoriginal.

Because the story takes place during the Ind This hasn't been my favorite Steinbeck book. Because the story takes place during the Industrial Revolution, the absence of female laborers really struck me.

Additionally, Steinbeck was known to do extensive research before writing his novels, so the lack of historical accuracy, with respect to women's critical presence in the work-force during the Industrial Revolution, was a bit unbelievable.

Then again, I try not to judge white, early 20th century American authors too harshly because they're a product of their time; we all are.

That aside, the overall plot and theme is very interesting. I want to give Steinbeck credit for what I did like.

It shows the way in which power can corrupt, even when those in power are fighting against even more powerful people. Mac, the head of The Party, is an example of this corruption, having used his authority to further The Party's agenda, with little regard for the lives that may be lost on that journey.

The ending is very solemn and thought-provoking. I do think this novel is worth reading, especially if you're a Steinbeck fan, as it provides some elements of classic Steinbeck working-class struggle and presents interesting questions and perspectives; it's good food for thought.

Having set myself a challenge of reading at least one Steinbeck book per month, I decided to tackle 'In Dubious Battle' this month due to interest within the Goodreads Ireland group to enjoy it as a Buddy Read.

Published in However, while this breakthrough was a relatively easy going book, very much in keeping with the future classic 'Cannery Row', 'In Dubious Battle' tackles more serious subject matter, Having set myself a challenge of reading at least one Steinbeck book per month, I decided to tackle 'In Dubious Battle' this month due to interest within the Goodreads Ireland group to enjoy it as a Buddy Read.

However, while this breakthrough was a relatively easy going book, very much in keeping with the future classic 'Cannery Row', 'In Dubious Battle' tackles more serious subject matter, portraying an apple pickers' strike orchestrated by 'the Party' which party is never made clear in a Californian valley.

The main action of the novel is held together by the following of Jim Nolan, a new member of the party, whose father was legendary in 'red' circles, and who becomes active under the mentorship of Mac, an experienced strike organiser, as they seek to organise the apple pickers in their fight for better terms from the farmers whose crops they are picking.

Initially, one feels sympathetic for the workers' cause, but as the book progresses, while the injustice of the poor conditions suffered by the workers is clear, the actions of the strikers, led by London but manipulated by Mac and Jim becomes increasingly ugly, and ultimately results in a tragic finale.

I absolutely loved this novel, as I have done the majority of the Steinbeck works I have read. In this narrative he writes simply yet vividly, and does a great job in guiding the readers' feelings about the strike, and no doubt the industrial unrest at the time, by commenting on the strike and its ideology through the impartial character of Doc Burton.

It sets the pattern for the later and more widely read 'Grapes of Wrath', and is a book that I'd recommend highly to everyone! No more lone cries came from lone men.

They moved together, looked alike. The roar was one voice, coming from many throats. This book had some of the most quotable moments I've read.

I liked it, although I didn't really love it. I felt the book was very obviously trying to make a point and so it felt heavy handed at times.

It was, however, a very educational look at the lives of migratory workers during the depression. He covers the topic in The Grapes of Wrath but this one was from the perspecti No more lone cries came from lone men.

He covers the topic in The Grapes of Wrath but this one was from the perspective of strikers. He shows all of the ways that the local power structure tried to prevent and break strikes, as well as all of the steps the strikers had to take to keep from running afoul of those laws.

And, not surprisingly, the laws were not on the side of the strikers. I have no true understanding of economics so it was actually fascinating to me to learn things like the majority of the apples were being disposed of to keep the prices artificially high.

Overall, it was interesting and I'm glad I read it, but I doubt I'll be reading it again soon. May 22, Susan Johnson rated it really liked it.

I had read "Grapes of Wrath" and "Mice and Men" in school and then never thought of him until Oprah made "East of Eden" a book club selection and I fell in love with Steinbeck.

This novel takes place in the 's in the Central Valley of Calif. Although the s 4. Although the strike is about apple pickers, Warren French who wrote the introduction, says it's based on a peach picker strike in Tulare County.

That part makes little difference. The story made me think of my maternal grandfather who was an almond rancher in the Northern Central Valley and I think probably had experiences similar to the people in the book.

Fruit pickers are really the bottom of the barrel jobs and tend to go to recent immigrants. In the book, the workers are Italians and Irish.

As they assimilate the workers became Hispanic and now many are Vietnamese and Hmong. As they are new to the country they seem to have lower expectations of proper working conditions which makes it easier to prey on.

In Dubious Battle

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail

3 thoughts on “In Dubious Battle

Leave a Comment